Propane refill near Indianapolis, IN
10 stations that refill your own tank (not just swap it). Posted prices checked September 6, 2026. Sorted cheapest first.
Quick math: a standard 20 lb grill tank holds about 4.7 gallons. At the lowest posted price here ($3.75/gal) a true fill runs about
$17.62 + tax. A swap-cage exchange tank typically comes back with only 15 lb — you pay for gas you don't get.
Why refill beats exchange →
| Station | Refill | Exchange | Today |
|---|
U-Haul Moving & Storage of Southern Plaza
4011 S East St, Indianapolis, IN 46227 |
$3.75/gal | — | Open today 9 am - 5 pm |
U-Haul of Lynhurst
5245 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46241 |
$3.75/gal | $24.95 | Open today 9 am - 5 pm |
U-Haul Moving & Storage at Keystone Plaza
5251 N Keystone Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220 |
$3.75/gal | — | Open today 9 am - 5 pm |
U-Haul Moving & Storage of Eastgate
7425 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46219 |
$3.75/gal | $24.95 | Open today 9 am - 5 pm |
U-Haul Moving & Storage at Shadeland Ave
2701 N Shadeland Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46219 |
$3.75/gal | $24.95 | Open today 9 am - 5 pm |
U-Haul Moving & Storage at Michigan Rd
6014 Michigan Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46228 |
$3.75/gal | — | Open today 9 am - 5 pm |
U-Haul Moving & Storage of Lawrence
6800 Pendleton Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46226 |
$3.95/gal | — | Open today 9 am - 5 pm |
U-Haul Moving & Storage of Castleton
7027 E 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46250 |
$4.25/gal | — | Open today 9 am - 5 pm |
U-Haul Moving & Storage of Eagledale
2960 Lafayette Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46222 |
$4.25/gal | — | Open today 9 am - 5 pm |
Station details
U-Haul Moving & Storage of Southern Plaza Lowest price
4011 S East St, Indianapolis, IN 46227 · (317) 787-6368 · 4.2 miles from downtown
Refill: $3.75/gal + taxAutogas: $3.61/gal
Mon-Thur: 7 am - 7 pm · Fri: 7 am - 8 pm · Sat: 7 am - 7 pm · Sun: 9 am - 5 pm
U-Haul of Lynhurst Lowest price
5245 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46241 · (317) 247-8101 · 5.1 miles from downtown
Refill: $3.75/gal + taxExchange: $24.95Autogas: $3.29/gal
Mon-Thur: 7 am - 7 pm · Fri: 7 am - 8 pm · Sat: 7 am - 7 pm · Sun: 9 am - 5 pm
U-Haul Moving & Storage at Keystone Plaza Lowest price
5251 N Keystone Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220 · (317) 257-4291 · 5.9 miles from downtown
Refill: $3.75/gal + taxAutogas: $3.61/gal
Mon-Thur: 7 am - 7 pm · Fri: 7 am - 8 pm · Sat: 7 am - 7 pm · Sun: 9 am - 5 pm
U-Haul Moving & Storage of Eastgate Lowest price
7425 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46219 · (317) 899-9990 · 6.3 miles from downtown
Refill: $3.75/gal + taxExchange: $24.95Autogas: $3.29/gal
Mon-Thur: 7 am - 7 pm · Fri: 7 am - 8 pm · Sat: 7 am - 7 pm · Sun: 9 am - 5 pm
U-Haul Moving & Storage at Shadeland Ave Lowest price
2701 N Shadeland Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46219 · (317) 546-1503 · 6.5 miles from downtown
Refill: $3.75/gal + taxExchange: $24.95Autogas: $3.29/gal
Mon-Thur: 7 am - 7 pm · Fri: 7 am - 8 pm · Sat: 7 am - 7 pm · Sun: 9 am - 5 pm
U-Haul Moving & Storage at Michigan Rd Lowest price
6014 Michigan Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46228 · (317) 257-5461 · 6.9 miles from downtown
Refill: $3.75/gal + taxAutogas: $3.61/gal
Mon-Thur: 7 am - 7 pm · Fri: 7 am - 8 pm · Sat: 7 am - 7 pm · Sun: 9 am - 5 pm
U-Haul Moving & Storage of Lawrence
6800 Pendleton Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46226 · (317) 829-6030 · 7.0 miles from downtown
Refill: $3.95/gal + taxAutogas: $3.61/gal
Mon-Thur: 7 am - 7 pm · Fri: 7 am - 8 pm · Sat: 7 am - 7 pm · Sun: 9 am - 5 pm
U-Haul Moving & Storage of Castleton
7027 E 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46250 · (317) 849-9614 · 11.6 miles from downtown
Refill: $4.25/gal + taxAutogas: $3.61/gal
Mon-Thur: 7 am - 7 pm · Fri: 7 am - 8 pm · Sat: 7 am - 7 pm · Sun: 9 am - 5 pm
U-Haul Moving & Storage of Eagledale
2960 Lafayette Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46222 · (317) 923-1508 · 4.4 miles from downtown
Refill: $4.25/gal + taxAutogas: $3.88/gal
Mon-Thur: 7 am - 7 pm · Fri: 7 am - 8 pm · Sat: 7 am - 7 pm · Sun: 9 am - 5 pm
Also refills propane (price not posted online)
U-Haul Moving & Storage of Noblesville
14296 Herriman Blvd, Noblesville, IN 46060 · (317) 770-0113 · 17.6 miles from downtown
Mon-Thur: 7 am - 7 pm · Fri: 7 am - 8 pm · Sat: 7 am - 7 pm · Sun: 9 am - 5 pm
Other places that refill propane in Indianapolis
Many Tractor Supply, Ace Hardware, Costco (members), farm co-ops and independent propane dealers also refill 20–100 lb cylinders and RV tanks. They don't publish live prices online, so we only list stations we can verify. Know one we're missing? Email us the address and we'll check it and add it.
Get a delivered price per gallon in Indianapolis
Home tank (100–1,000 gallons)? The per-gallon delivered price is the number that matters, and suppliers rarely post it. Tell us what you need and one local supplier that serves Indianapolis will call or email you a price. Free, no obligation, no list — one supplier, one call.
We hand your request to one propane supplier serving your ZIP; they contact you directly. Not sold to lead lists.
Worth having before you go
Three cheap things that pay for themselves on the first refill: a tank gauge so you stop swapping half-full tanks, a 1 lb bottle refill adapter if you run camp stoves or a Buddy heater, and a new 20 lb cylinder if yours is past its 12-year date (the station will refuse it).
Bulk delivery for a home tank is a different service from cylinder refill — get delivery quotes above.
Source: prices and hours as posted on each station's own listing on September 6, 2026. View source.